Connect with us

Spectrum

FCC Considering Rules to Share Terrestrial Spectrum with Satellite Service Providers

Satellite sharing on terrestrial spectrum is premature, said satellite and terrestrial providers.

Published

on

Photo of Alison Minea of Dish Network

WASHINGTON, July 14, 2023 – Commenters claim that the Federal Communications Commission’s proposed rules that would make it easier for satellite service providers to get access to already-licensed mobile wireless spectrum to help on-the-ground mobile wireless companies cover dead spots they can’t reach are “premature” and could be competitively harmful.  

The FCC proposed rules in March to implement a framework through which satellite operators collaborating with terrestrial service providers could obtain authorization to operate space stations on certain licenses spectrum. The framework would facilitate satellite to smartphone supplemental coverage. 

Satellite providers and terrestrial providers alike urged the FCC to take more precaution in implementing the rules.

“Supplemental coverage from space can expand access to emergency communications for consumers and first responders in addition to extending the reach of terrestrial networks,” said Alison Minea, vice president of regulatory Affairs at Dish in a statement with satellite providers EchoStar and Hughes Network Systems. “However, given the risk of harmful interference to existing adjacent bands and adjacent country and international services, the companies urge the FCC to take a cautious, incremental approach,” it continued. 

Dish urged the FCC to take the necessary steps to ensure that sharing on the bands would not unduly increase risk to unacceptable interference that would create market confusion and delay adoption of the “important technology.” Failure to do so would allow other countries to take the lead in SCS capabilities, it stated. 

Mobile provider Verizon highlighted several key principles to address before the marketplace can deliver on the promise of SCS. Implementation of SCS must hinge on a wireless provider’s decision to partner with a satellite operator and any SCS offering must protect terrestrial wireless operations from harmful interference, read its comments. 

Verizon asked the FCC to first provide “clear and predicable guidelines to support case-by-case evaluation” to encourage the development of the SCS market while ensuring terrestrial service is not harmed. “It would be premature to adopt a new regulatory regime, and doing so could needlessly hamper the very services this proceeding seeks to advance,” read its comments. 

It suggested that the FCC adopt a waiver-based approach that would place the burden on SCS applicants to demonstrate that their service will meet robust technical safeguards to protect mobile operators. This would promote competition and provide terrestrial operators with “ample flexibility” to utilize SCS in the way best suited for their network, added Michael Goggin, general attorney at AT&T in comments. 

AT&T said that the FCC “should proceed cautiously and ensure that its deployment does not disrupt the thriving terrestrial mobile broadband networks that consumers rely on.” 

“Connecting mobile devices to satellites may hold promise for the future, but the technology for SCS is still in its infancy,” it continued. It suggested that the FCC’s regulatory approach be guided by its goals to protect terrestrial licenses and networks, ensure SCS is inherently supplemental, and maintain long term competition and innovation. 

The Rural Wireless Association urged the FCC to be more inclusive of wireless carriers in the definition of qualifying terrestrial providers. According to RWA, “only certain nationwide, statewide, or territory-wide license holders would be eligible to enter into leasing arrangements with satellite operators” according to currently proposed rules. 

Spectrum sharing is a major topic of discussion within the FCC. Spectrum bands, frequencies that wireless signals travel over, are becoming increasingly sparse due to its finite nature. The FCC lost its authority to auction spectrum authority to the highest bidder earlier this year. 

Contributing Reporter Teralyn Whipple, who joined Broadband Breakfast in 2022, studied marketing at Brigham Young University. She has reported extensively on broadband infrastructure, investments and deployment. She has also headed marketing campaigns for several small companies.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Broadband's Impact

CES 2024: NTIA and House Commerce Weigh in on Spectrum Policy

Reinstating FCC auction authority is the ‘number one priority’ of the Energy and Commerce Committee Chair.

Published

on

Photo of the panel by Jake Neenan

LAS VEGAS, January 12, 2024 – A senior National Telecommunications and Information Administration advisor and the chief lawyers for both Democratic and Republican sides of the House Subcommittee on Communications and Technology talked about their spectrum policy priorities on Thursday at CES.

The group touted U.S. wins at the World Radiocommunication Conference in Dubai, as well as lawmakers’ goals for spectrum auction authority heading into 2024.

World Radio Congress

Going into the conference, in which representatives from around the world meet to coordinate spectrum usage, “the 6 GigaHertz (GHz) issue was the top priority of the U.S. government,” said Phil Murphy, a senior advisor at the NTIA.

The band was set aside in 2020 by the Federal Communications Commission for unlicensed use in the United States, but some countries like China wanted to see some of the band tapped for 5G mobile use, Murphy said.

The U.S. delegation was ultimately able to deliver in December: the conference decision set aside 700 MegaHertz (MHz) for mobile, but left the door open for regulatory agencies to approve unlicensed use throughout the band.

That’s a win for the American Wi-Fi industry: the Wi-Fi alliance announced its official Wi-Fi 7 certification on Monday ahead of the tech conference. The new generation supports wider spectrum channels and multi-link operation, both of which will make use of the 1,200 MHz of real estate in the 6 GHz band.

“We’re really excited by the results,” Murphy said. “We’re really excited to see 6 GHz moving forward, not just here in the United States, but in other parts of the world as well.”

Auction authority

The Federal Communications Commission’s authority to auction and issue licenses for the commercial use of electromagnetic spectrum expired for the first time in March 2023. That’s not an issue for technologies like Wi-Fi, which don’t require such licenses to operate in bands set aside for unlicensed use, but it is important for ever-expanding 5G networks and wireless broadband.

“The Chair’s number one priority is to reauthorize the FCC spectrum auction authority that expired in March,” said Kate O’Connor, chief counsel for the Republican majority on the communications and technology subcommittee. “Even if it hasn’t been public, there’s been a lot going on behind the scenes.”

Jennifer Epperson, chief counsel for the Democratic side of the subcommittee, and Murphy, the NTIA advisor, agreed on the importance of the issue. 

“I think reauthorizing the FCC’s spectrum auction authority is a priority for the administration as well,” he said. “There’s probably spectrum that the FCC has available to auction right now, but they can’t because they don’t have the authority to do so.”

At a House oversight hearing in November, FCC Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel said “I have a bunch of bands sitting in the closet at the FCC,” pointing to 550 MHz in the 12.7-13.25 GHz band as spectrum the agency could go to auction with “relatively quickly.”

Efforts at blanket reauthorization have stalled publicly since a bill cleared the House Energy and Commerce Committee in May, but a stopgap measure allowing the Commission to issue licenses that had been purchased before the lapse was signed into law in December.

“With the funding bills coming up, we’re taking a look and hoping that we can turn this on as soon as possible,” O’Connor said.

Continue Reading

Spectrum

CES 2024: NTIA to Release Spectrum Strategy Implementation Plan in March

The plan will hand down start dates and timelines for the strategy’s goals.

Published

on

LAS VEGAS, January 11, 2024 – The National Telecommunications and Information Administration is planning to have an implementation plan for the National Spectrum Strategy in March, a senior agency official said at CES on Thursday.

“We have an implementation plan that’s going to be out sometime in March,” said Phil Murphy, a senior advisor at the NTIA. “We’re really excited about the next steps.” 

The White House first unveiled the plan in November. It involves studying nearly 2,800 megahertz of spectrum for potential repurposing amid growing commercial demand. The plan also calls for a revamped spectrum pipeline with increased communication between government agencies and the private sector, as well as establishing a testbed for spectrum sharing.

The Biden administration also tasked the NTIA with producing an implementation plan within 120 days, putting the planned March release near the end of the agency’s window.

The implementation plan will, according to the NTIA, set up specific outcomes for each of the strategy’s “strategic objectives.” The plan will also designate responsible parties and set out start dates and timelines for their work.

Those strategic objectives are peppered throughout the strategy document, numbering 12 in total. They include ensuring spectrum resources are available for government and the private sector, developing an evidence-based spectrum allocation methodology, a spectrum research and development plan, and improving policymakers’ understanding of spectrum issues.

The agency took public comments on the implementation plan until January 2.

Continue Reading

Spectrum

CES 2024: More Spectrum and Auction Authority Necessary for 5G

The White House released a long-term spectrum plan in November, but the FCC still lacks auction authority.

Published

on

Photo of the panel by Jake Neenan

LAS VEGAS, January 9, 2024 – More spectrum will be necessary to expand 5G mobile networks in the United States, experts said at CES on Tuesday.

“We need to not only open up more spectrum bands, we need to use them as efficiently as possible,” said Chris Lewis, president and CEO of consumer advocacy group Public Knowledge.

Lewis cited as a step in the right direction the National Spectrum Strategy, a plan put forward by the White House in November to study almost 2,800 MHz for potential repurposing and to set up a long-term spectrum planning framework.

Beefing up the nation’s spectrum pipeline, as well as promoting unlicensed use and dynamic spectrum sharing, should be positive for 5G adoption going forward, Lewis said.

The plan “set down the right principles to move forward,” he said.

For all that to come to fruition, the Federal Communications Commission will need its spectrum auction authority renewed, something the Commission has been pushing lawmakers on. Congress let the authority lapse for the first time in March, and efforts to reinstate it have stalled. 

A stopgap measure was passed in December allowing the Commission to issue licenses that had been purchased before the lapse. Those will be used, largely by T-Mobile, to expand 5G footprints.

The World Radiocommunications Conference also tapped in December several hundred megahertz of spectrum for licensed, mobile use globally, part of an effort to help satiate the demand for growing 5G networks.

Some of that has already been reserved for Wi-Fi and other unlicensed use in the United States.

Chris Emmons, vice president of devices and accessories at Verizon, said freeing up more spectrum would allow the company to continue expanding home broadband on its 5G networks. Some states have flagged concerns about the capacity on those networks, as cell traffic is prioritized during congestion, but Emmons said fixed wireless broadband is more adequate on 5G networks than on previous standards.

“Fixed wireless access for consumers has been a dream for a long time,” he said. “There were 3G attempts, there were 4G attempts… There have been a lot of things that people have tried over the years, but we’ve actually seen a fixed wireless solution now that scales successfully.”

“As long as we continue to get the spectrum we need, we will engineer that properly and provide for all these use cases,” Emmons said.

Continue Reading

Signup for Broadband Breakfast News



Broadband Breakfast Research Partner

Trending